Why do you want an accountability partner/coach/whatever for writing?

The things you most dislike about your job, and that you would not do if an external body did not require them, have accountability to that external body built in.

You do your grading. You do it by the institutional deadline. You set aside important work to do it. (I have never heard of anyone missing this aspect of academic work when they leave.)

Your writing and research is the reason you ended up doing a PhD and becoming an academic. You want to do this. You also have external accountability in the form of promotion guidelines, tenure requirements, and so on.

You don’t need accountability. You need confidence.

You need to believe that this work that you want to do and that you love doing (even when you hate it) is real work.

You need to believe that you deserve the time to do this work.

You need to believe that given the choice, you do the right things.

What’s wrong with accountability?

AcCOUNTability leads you to focus on the things you can count:

• words
• publications
• rates of production of words or publications
• time spent doing tasks that look like Real Work

At the institutional level, we identify this as bureaucracy and are critical of its application to the creative work of knowledge production. And yet, at the personal level, the “chimera of absolute transparency, consistency and fairness” is indeed (if perversely) attractive. (Graeber, in Glaser, Bureaucracy: Why won’t scholars break their paper chains, THE, May 21, 2015)

If not acCOUNTability, then what?

If, as Graeber argues, “at the heart of bureaucracy is a fear of play, of creativity” and if “numerous studies illustrate how creativity is inhibited by the restriction of autonomy, the hallmark of bureaucracy” then claiming freedom and autonomy and making time for play and creativity is the solution.

You need trust

Trust in the creative process (and a willingness to face other fears along the way like fear of success, fear of being too big, fear of rejection, …).

Trust that your institution will recognize and accept the outputs of your creative process.

Trust that others will read your work.

Trust that others will be inspired by your work.

Trust that others will acknowledge your role in the creation of that knowledge.

You will also benefit from support

Support that helps you trust.

Support that builds your confidence.

Support that reinforces your permission to play.

Support that acknowledges that creative work is not always countable.

The problem with accountability is that it may be effective at getting you to write and finish things but at the cost of eroding your trust and confidence.

What kind of support would help you do the creative work you want and need to do?

If you would benefit from some help figuring that out, Foundations of on Academic Writing Practice is designed to help you figure out what kind of practice would work for you, and build that practice into your routine. It is based on the principle that what works for you is not necessarily what works for others, and that your practice needs to change and adapt over time.

Related posts:

Thoughts on accountability, deadlines, goals and so on.

You are not Lazy

I’ve written a series of posts on Confidence, you might start with Where does confidence come from? Part 3: support

Edited to add related posts June 1, 2017.