What if someone wrote “quit lit” as an actual novel? A genre novel. A romance.
Academic studies examining the reasons are important. Personal essays giving insight into the variety of experiences are also important.
But sometimes you want a story that acknowledges your frustrations and gives you hope that even if you can’t see another option, just quitting might not be terrible.
Philippa Flynn’s Year of Panic and Piracy by Jacqueline Firkins, does just that.
Leaving academia is an emotional journey as much, or more, than a practical one. One of the things about romance as a genre is that it’s mainly about emotion. It makes you feel things. And resolves them into a happy ending.
Leaving isn’t failure
Since I read Jacqueline’s book, findings of a large scale quantitative study of faculty retention in US PhD granting institutions have been published, showing that the most gendered reason people leave faculty jobs is NOT work-life balance, but feeling devalued.
“Women professors are more likely to leave their jobs than men. While many efforts to improve the retention of women faculty focus on work–life balance, our large-scale survey of current and former faculty across nearly 300 institutions reveals that the most gendered workplace factor among respondents is feeling devalued, both in formal evaluations and daily interactions.”
Philippa Flynn, the main character in this novel, leaves for just this reason. She is a successful academic. She has tenure. She has published 3 monographs. You will need to suspend disbelief about her age, but these facts are important to establish the narrative. She is decidedly NOT a failure.
After narrowly missing falling into a sink hole as she cycles to work one day, Philippa makes the apparently impulsive decision to quit. The first chapter sets out the context and reasons really well. And those reasons add up to exactly what Katie Spoon and her colleagues found in their very serious research. Jacqueline Firkins tips her hat to The Professor Is In community in her acknowledgements so this is not at all surprising.
If you are feeling devalued and looking for a fun way to address your frustrations, I thoroughly recommend this very fun romance novel for your leisure reading.
Leaving is often a let down
The realistic thing about the opening of this book, as Jennifer Polk of PhD to Life pointed out when I interviewed her for an upcoming podcast episode, is the reactions Philippa gets to her decision. Jen summarizes:
“The thing that I found most real is the reactions of the people around her.
It’s the reaction of her department chair, who doesn’t even say thank you or good luck or anything like that.
There’s the reaction of her friend, who’s an English professor, the only person that she’s become close with at her institution.
And her initial reaction is: “I didn’t realise you applied for another job.”
The assumption that she could only be leaving for a different academic job.
And the reaction of her family members, which is, “Oh, of course you’re already applying to other academic jobs”, and then the immediate pivot to “Well, how about working in a museum, an archive?”
Like I said a few minutes ago, that immediate kind of assumption of what she’s right for.
She has to go away from everybody. She has to physically go away from all of this to figure it out herself.”
Like Jen, I had this immediate recognition as I read the first chapter or so of this book. (The beginning is typically available as a free sample that your favourite ebook retailer offers before purchase.)
The Panic…
Philippa Flynn has a bit of a safety net. She’s inherited a house from her grandmother, so at least she has a roof over her head while she figures out her next steps. It’s a roof that requires a bucket routine every time it rains, literally and metaphorically.
There isn’t a lot of money but her grandmother was an author with fans, so there are also things Philippa can sell to raise some short term cash. And while her relationships with her parents and siblings are tense, she can go to them for a loan if she needs to.
This is more than some people have but a lot less than most people think they need to leave. Hence the panic.
It means that the question of how she can earn a living is rather urgent.
Leaving a specific job? Or leaving academia?
This is a romance, so the spine of the story is about the romance that develops (slowly) between her and her grandmother’s assistant who has been living in the house (as per the terms of the will).
However, the story is as much about Philippa figuring out if she really wants to leave academia, or just that particular job, and figuring out what else she might do.
It’s not a story of love making everything okay, nor of solving the problem by marrying a rich man. That would be annoying.
The conflict many feel as they make this decision is externalized in Philippa’s relationship to her mother, who really pushes on many of the main social pressures for people of this class and background. The fact that she has some actual legal power to thwart one of Philippa’s future career options adds depth to this conflict.
The love interest is one of the people who offers a different perspective on success and on Philippa’s strengths. He, along with Phiippa’s friend from her old job, and memories of her grandmother, provide a counterbalance to the powerful cultural stories personified by the parents.
This is where the pirates come in, but I won’t spoil that for you.
Happily Ever After …
If you aren’t familiar with the genre, one of the main features, apart from the falling in love part, is the Happily Ever After (HEA).
Philippa Flynn’s HEA isn’t just about falling in love and sailing off into the sunset. It includes working out what a satisfying career might be after leaving academia, hot pirate optional.
The particular career she ends up pursuing may seem preposterous, but it isn’t really any more preposterous than the idea of getting a tenure track job as a historian in the current climate.
And the way we get there is a whole lot of fun!
Related Links & Posts:
Read more about and get the book on Jacqueline’s website here.
“Devaluation underlies gendered US faculty departures across disciplines and institutions” by Katie Spoon, et al PNAS Nexus, Volume 5, Issue 10, October 2026
For a hernia that sparked a life and career change: “The Limits of Refusal” by Shannon Mattern
The importance of quitting by JoVE
Jumping off cliffs by JoVE
This post was sent to newsletter subscribers 25 November 2026.








